| 2023 | Deborah Beete | Public Health Sciences |
| Honored as Finalists: | |
| Jeanne-Marie “Ree” Linker | Mathematics and Statistics |
| Hannah Peach | Psychological Science |
| | |
| 2022 | Terry Shirley Jr. | Geography & Earth Sciences |
| | Honored as Finalists: | |
| | Carol Higham | History |
| | Cheryl Kane | Management |
| | | |
| 2021 | Kathryn Asala | Chemistry |
| | Honored as Finalists: | |
| | Mitch Eisner | Reading and Elementary Education |
| | Tonya Wertz-Orbaugh | Writing, Rhetoric, and Digital Studies |
| | | |
| 2020 | Tonya C. Bates | Biological Sciences |
| | Honored as Finalists: | |
| | Susana Cisneros | Languages and Culture Studies |
| | Kathleen Nicolaides | Criminal Justice and Criminology |
| | | |
| 2019 | Thomas Marshall | Finance |
| | Honored as Finalists: | |
| | Oscar Lansen | History |
| | Terry Shirley, Jr. | Geography and Earth Sciences |